EIRENE Streamlining, Code Camp FZJ

4 Nov 2021, 09:00 → 10 Nov 2021, 18:20 Europe/Berlin

Bldg. 9.1 "IPP-A", Large Seminar Room (ZOOM <NGM_CC21>)

Thursday 4 November ¶

09:00 → 13:45 Arrival, getting started, bilateral talks, etc.¶

12:30 Joint taxi from DUS airport (12:30?..)¶

13:45 → 14:00 FORMAL START. Greetings, agenda approval, misc.¶

14:00 → 16:00 A1: Version and simulation case(s) for streamlining¶

Mapping of the main branches, challenges
Expected output: any merging work that can be done during code camp, make sure the starting branch develop_openmp has all the requested features, e.g. Jorge’s tallies work)
Master input file; possible variations, testing focuses

Convener: Yannick Marandet (CEA)

14:00 Overview of the EIRENE versions¶

10-15 min talk + questions

Speaker: Petra Boerner

Eirene_branches.pptx

16:00 → 16:20 Break (20 min)

16:20 → 18:20 B1: Grouping of variables into structures¶

(within modules, no IMAS)

Convener: Jorge Gonzalez (DIFFER)

16:20 Characteristic examples¶

Experience from tallies output to HDF5: coding samples, useful constructions, suggested style...

Speaker: Jorge Gonzalez (DIFFER)

2021-11-04 Eirene Streamlining.pdf

peopleTYPE.zip

1. Where it will be relevant to group variables:
   1. Improves performance
   2. Improves code readability
   3. Results in a more flexible code for current or future developments.
2. Possible impacts of variable grouping:
   1. Relevant reduction in performance.
   2. Impact in pre/post-processing tools.
   3. Coupling with plasma codes.
   4. Rewriting time is to large for the reduced benefit.
   5. Private/public variables.
   6. Cache.
3. Possible points to apply variable grouping:
   1. Particles
   2. Geometry, starting with coordinates.
   3. MPI broadcasting

Friday 5 November ¶

09:30 → 12:30 B2. Grouping variables in a view of core segregation¶

--> working session I on variable grouping (specific branch selected for the core segregation, see session A1)
Large focus on joint coding and detailed decisions.
--> One should identify and group variables absolutely necessary for the main loop.

Conveners: Yannick Marandet (CEA), Dmitriy Borodin (FZJ)

12:30 → 13:45 Lunch

Regular bus to "Seecasino" leaves 12:30!

13:45 → 15:00 Discussion/report/feedback on the coding advancement¶

Speaker: ALL

1) Can we improve geometry treatment?

 --> Cell relevance to the stratas (surfaces) to be reviewed  (PB, Monday morning session)

 --> Can one bring this together with the OcTree version (Oliver Bertuch)

--> Should we consider using an abstract cell type uniform for all existing cell types (DB)?..

 

2) Should we move particle intializations out of the main loop??? 

 

3) Streamlining of the main loop

 --> Define particle initial conditions type (JG); in future also trajectory type

--> Use of modules to be localized to the relevant routines

--> Link cells with the relevant additional surfaces

--> The parameters affected by the routines should be given explicitely as arguments; the routine input should also be made as explicit as possible. 

--> Modularize the routines where possible using utility functions (with "contain")

--> Make shorter and "cleaner" functions (consider using inlining) (JG/DH - formulate more clearly, test "pure" subtoutune directive)

 

4) Reconsider variable structure in EIRENE

 --> group variables using TYPEs

--> reconsider using large arrays allocated and used by distributed pointers (also from the point of view of HPC broadcasting; mind the cashing by the exersize).

 

(I) This excersize helps to improve

     a) joint expertise and mutual understanding on the code writing priciples

     b) reduce "learning barier" for newcommers

15:00 → 18:00 B3. Grouping of variables into structures (for IMASification)¶

(IO related : geometry, tallies)

Convener: Dmitriy Borodin (FZJ)

1) Things suitable for outsourcing to ACH

    a|) Utility routines to build GDB objects (Thomas Johnson) - not EIRENE specific! Just theatraeders for instance (for all EIRENE geometry types).

    b) Interpolation and extaction routnes.

 

2) Basically B2.5-EIRENE is IMASIfied from the fluid side for output. Still, there are variables in EIRENE worth IMASification, not seeable from the B2.5 IDSs

     a) statistical vaiances

     b) all, what is ouside the B2 grid (extended grid and more).

     c) CRM internal data

     d) Emission data with EIRENE resolution (processes, lines, cells, etc)

     e) Particular processes, surfaces etc. defined inside EIRENE

     f) metadata specific for EIRENE (code library node)

     g) make IMAS from base files describing geometry

     k) provide conversion tools for grid types (e.g. quadragular to thriangular)

 

3) EIRENE as an NGM should be IMASified independent on B2.5

      a) keep B2.5 IDSs as a basis for other fluid codes (starting with SOLEDGE3X). Flag where generalisation is needed.

      b) Start trasforming common variables between B2.5 and EIRENE into IMAS (long term!!)

          ==> Best to do after the streamlining and total version merge!

          ==> Data structure developed by streamling should keep in mind future IMASification.

      c) Start with IMAS input for EIRENE

          ==> adding cortesian velocity componets

          ==> incorporate ways to use the machine description DB 

 

 

 

15:00 IMAS in SOLPS-ITER (EIRENE side): status and outlook¶

Participation from ITER confirmed

Speaker: Dr Xavier Bonnin (ITER IO)

IMAS_for_EIRENE.pptx

16:00 Break (20 min)

Monday 8 November ¶

09:00 → 11:00 S1. Working session with focus on core segregation.¶

Convener: Dmitriy Borodin (FZJ)

geometry_considerations.pptx

1) Analyse random generator for harmful variations
  -- Random and MPI/OpenMP
  -- ACH task?..

2) Improving  presorting of additional surfaces.

  -- available routinges provide good starting point 
  -- OcTree is available (3-5 points surface polygons)
 

3) Handling the grid - single geometry option should be aimed. Not just OOP, but streamling the basic math.

 

10:45 Break (15 min)

11:00 → 12:30 EIRENE Versioning (merge strategy)¶

Convener: Yannick Marandet (CEA)

1) Add sripts, compiler configuration files and postprocessing.

2) Move manual into the same repository as the source

3)  Merge of the instructured version of the SOLPS-ITER should be taken care about

 

More general items:

1) Git rebase is not be used

2) Var names (applied to new code parts)

   -- Use capitals to underline name parts

   -- no type indications (except for pointers, etc?.. needs really good motivatgion)

3)

   -- warning tolerance --> 0 

 

 

12:30 → 13:45 Lunch

Regular bus to "Seecasino" leaves 12:30!

13:45 → 15:00 Discussion/report/feedback on the coding advancement¶

Speaker: ALL

15:00 → 18:00 B4. Variable structure in the streamlined version¶

Convener: Jorge Gonzalez (DIFFER)

16:00 Break (20 min)

Tuesday 9 November ¶

09:00 → 12:30 S2. Code segregation in the streamlined version¶

Convener: Yannick Marandet (CEA)

eirene_branch_merging.pptx

1) We do cosider streamlining of the CR part

       -- Go abstract reaction type (DB)

       -- Reconsider MODCOL (reaction type, fitting type, N insiede reaction type)

       -- Unloading the main loop (fpath.f) from branching (is it really worth the effort?..)

       -- Tracking of internal states can be done based on external preparation

 

3) To be liasoned with YACORA, suggesting 2 options:

     -- YACORA will be the basis, but we should provide the access layer

     -- Alternatively we create our our standalone preparation tool (starting with HydKin and using YACORA data if allowed + Original data)

    

 

2) Runtime error handling should be reconsidered (DB)

 

11:00 Break (15 min)

12:30 → 13:45 Lunch

Regular bus to "Seecasino" leaves 12:30!

13:45 → 15:00 Discussion/report/feedback on the coding advancement¶

Speaker: ALL

15:00 → 18:00 EIRENE toy model (developed with ACH)¶

Sceleton version most suitable for testing of various parallelisation schemes

Convener: Oscar Lappi (ACH-VTT)

toy_model.pptx

15:00 EIRENE Toy model: aims, current development status¶

Speaker: Oscar Lappi (ACH-VTT)

Eiron__EIRENE_toy_model.pdf

16:00 Break (20 min)

19:30 → 21:30 Social Dinner (in Jülich, outside FZJ)

Wednesday 10 November ¶

09:30 → 10:15 Discussion/report/feedback on the coding advancement¶

Speaker: ALL

10:15 → 14:35 Wrap-up and future plans¶

Reports on the sessions (10 min each?..)
Final discussion

10:20 The streamlined version - status and outlook¶

Speaker: Yannick Marandet (CEA)

summary_of_discussion_streamlining.pptx

10:35 Decisions on the variable structures¶

Speaker: Jorge Gonzalez (DIFFER)

2021-11-10 Conclusions.pptx

10:50 Progress and plans regarding the core segregation¶

Speaker: Dmitriy Borodin (FZJ)

SumICoreSeg_DB.pptx

11:05 EIRENE IMASification¶

Speaker: Dmitriy Borodin (FZJ)

SumIMAS_DB.pptx

11:20 Break (15 min)

11:35 Final Discussion¶

Speaker: Dmitriy Borodin (FZJ)

12:30 → 13:45 Lunch

Regular bus to "Seecasino" leaves 12:30!

14:35 → 15:00 Fixing the meeting points and adjorn¶

Speaker: Dmitriy Borodin (FZJ)

15:00 → 18:00 Final working session: issues and solutions¶

Convener: Dmitriy Borodin (FZJ)